Profitual × Brand Butter

This one's for Profitual.

A private growth proposal, prepared by Brand Butter.
Enter the access code from your email to continue.

That's not it. Check the code in your email and try again.

Prepared exclusively for Ray Fitzpatrick & the Profitual team · August 2026

Book the Thursday callBook Thursday Accept the proposal
Profitual × Brand Butter

You know your runway.
Now let's build your pipeline. momentum. trust. launch. next move.

Profitual gives business owners clarity on their numbers. This proposal gives Profitual clarity on its growth: a focused, measurable marketing engine that gives v2 the public moment it deserves, then compounds for the six months after it. Built for your push beyond startups into the broader world of business owners and their advisors, and around one non-negotiable rule we heard loud and clear on our call: prove the ROI before scaling the spend.

See the plan Skip to the investment Counting down to launch…
Scroll
01 · What we heard

A strong company with a quiet megaphone.

Ray, here's our read of last Thursday's conversation. Profitual's fundamentals are enviable. What's missing isn't product, cash, or conviction. It's a marketing system that converts attention into ARR.

$0
Cash reserves. Patience without complacency.
$0
ARR, built cash-flow efficient.
0 yrs
Runway. Time to grow deliberately, not desperately.
$0/mo
Your comfort zone for marketing spend, contingent on demonstrated ROI.

“We've tried webinars, LinkedIn, newsletter ads… nothing really stuck.”

The channels weren't wrong. They were disconnected. Signups arrived with nowhere structured to go, so interest evaporated before it became revenue.

“Startups love us, but they don't have the budget.”

Your instinct to widen beyond startups is right. The market is every business that wants to be intimate with its numbers, from owner-led SMEs to the accountants and bookkeepers who advise them, and it needs messaging built for buyers with revenue to protect.

“Selling software is about trust. People need to be educated first.”

This is the thesis of our whole plan. Education isn't a marketing tactic for Profitual. It's the product's front door, and we intend to build the whole engine around it.

02 · The diagnosis

It was never a channel problem.
It's a system problem.

Cold outreach at $4k a month, webinars, promotions: each was a solo act with no supporting cast. Here's what was actually breaking, and why it's very fixable.

Finding No. 1

Leaks, not droughts

Webinars pulled real signups. Then nothing followed them: no nurture, no structured path from curious to customer. The top of your funnel worked; the middle didn't exist.

Finding No. 2

Aimed at empty wallets

The early startup ICP meant winning buyers who couldn't afford to stay. Established owner-led businesses have the problem and the budget, and the accounting firms and bookkeepers who serve hundreds of them multiply every win.

Finding No. 3

Spend without a scoreboard

You paid for activity, not evidence. Without attribution and reporting, every dollar felt like a gamble, so scaling spend never felt justified. We fix the scoreboard first.

03 · The plan

Five moves. One compounding engine.

Each pillar feeds the next: sharper targeting makes the launch land, the launch feeds the trust engine, trust fills the pipeline, and the scoreboard proves it all deserves more fuel.

Pillar 01 · in The Spread & The Churn

ICP & Positioning Sprint

A two-week sprint to define who Profitual serves next, in tiers rather than a blur: primary, owner-led businesses with real revenue that want to be intimate with their numbers; secondary, accounting firms and bookkeepers, who are both customers and a distribution channel, since one firm advises dozens of businesses. We rebuild messaging around their language (runway, cash confidence, decisions) so every later tactic has a clear target.

Tiered ICPOwner & advisor messagingCompetitive angleSales-ready narrative
01
Pillar 02 · the Release Window add-on

The Release & the Ramp

Straight talk first: launches are inherently underwhelming, and modern marketing doesn't reward one loud day. So here's our recommendation, since Ray has said the date can move: split it in two. Engineering ships v2 to existing users the moment it's ready, quietly, for real usage and feedback. The public moment (webinars, campaign, feature videos, the noise) lands Wednesday, September 30, when the machine is loaded instead of rushed. Nobody delays the product; we only delay the fireworks. And before a dollar moves, we put honest traction expectations in writing so nobody is grading week one against month six.

Sept 30 moment (proposed)Quiet ship, loud momentCampaign creativeWebinar & email pushVideo packagingExpectation benchmarks
02
Pillar 03 · in The Spread & The Churn

The Trust Engine

You said it yourself: software is sold on trust, and trust is built through education. We turn your existing customers into proof (testimonials, mini case studies) and your expertise into an always-on education layer that warms buyers before sales ever says hello. It includes a full SEO overhaul, delivered as a prescription: we audit, we hand your team the exact changes to make, and nobody invents an agency dependency where none is needed. It also hands you credibility assets for conversations with partners like Mastercard and Visa.

Testimonial pipelineCase studiesEducation-led contentSEO overhaul (prescribed)Partner-ready proof
03
Pillar 04 · in The Churn

Demand: Paid, Nurtured & Partnered

We're not rebuying cold outreach; the market already graded that experiment. Attention gets bought where intent lives: search ads on the terms buyers actually type, paid webinar-registration campaigns, and retargeting for the people already circling. Behind it, we repair what happens after the signup: nurture sequences, webinar-to-trial paths, proof at the decision point. The outbound muscle goes only where the math works: high-touch partnerships with a shortlist of accounting and bookkeeping firms, where one yes means dozens of customers. Paid switches on in week four, once tracking is validated, and scales only when the scoreboard says so.

Paid with intentNurture sequencesWebinar-to-trial pathsAdvisor shortlist (~20 firms)Zero cold-email spend
04
Pillar 05 · in The Spread & The Churn

The Prove-It Scoreboard

A monthly ROI report a CFO would respect (fitting, given your product): pipeline created, cost per qualified lead, webinar-to-trial conversion, and what we're doubling down on or killing. You said spend scales only when the numbers earn it. We're building the instrument that decides.

Attribution setupMonthly ROI reportKill / scale decisionsFull transparency
05
04 · The runway

A launch is a day.
This is a six-month engine.

Thu · Sept 3

Proposal debrief

We reconvene once Matt is back, walk through this plan, decide the v2 moment date together (our vote: September 30), and lock scope without anyone rushing a decision.

Week 1 · Sept 4–10

Strategy & onboarding

Kickoff, access and analytics review, audience and offer refinement, channel priorities, and baseline measurement, so month six can be compared to day one.

Week 2 · Sept 11–17

Build (and ship quietly, if ready)

Creative concepts, messaging, landing and conversion work, tracking setup. If engineering ships v2 to existing users this week, all the better: real usage and testimonials in hand before the public ever hears a drumroll.

Week 3 · Sept 18–24

Production

Final creative, ICP and list development, email sequences, feature-video packaging, technical QA. Everything staged and rehearsed, nothing improvised.

Week 4 · Sept 25–30 Sept 30 · the v2 moment

The public moment, fully loaded

Coordinated push across webinars, email, social and advisor partners, with paid campaigns (search, webinar registration, retargeting) switching on behind validated conversion tracking, not guesses.

Weeks 5–6

Learn & optimize

First real data arrives. Creative and targeting adjustments, messaging refinement, and the first performance review, cost per qualified lead by channel included, against the baselines we set in week one.

Months 2–3

Build momentum

Scale what works, kill what doesn't, introduce additional campaigns and content, and push conversion rates up with every cycle.

Months 4–6

Compound

Optimize the full system: expand winning channels and audiences, improve efficiency, and grow marketing's contribution to pipeline month over month. This is where engines beat launches.

05 · The investment

Priced for proof, built to scale.

The five pillars map straight onto the pricing: the monthly plans carry the engine (Pillars 01, 03, 04, 05), and the v2 release window (Pillar 02) is its own one-time package. All figures CAD; the engagement runs six months, because anyone promising results in three is promising overnight results, and those don't exist. Ad spend sits outside these fees as a media budget you control, paid straight to the platforms.

The numbers are under the lid.

No second password, no games. One click and the butter melts.

Numbers negotiable in structure, never in accountability. Every plan includes the Prove-It Scoreboard, because you shouldn't have to take our word for anything.

06 · Why Brand Butter

Strategy first. Everything else follows.

We've done the homework

This proposal was built from your numbers, your channels, your ICP shift, and your launch date. Expect the same specificity every month, not templates with your logo pasted on.

Senior hands, no telephone game

You talk to the people doing the work. Decisions happen in days, not sprints-about-sprints. With a four-week runway to the v2 moment and a six-month engine to build, that speed matters twice.

Aligned with your caution

You want ROI proven before spend scales. So do we: our best clients are the ones who grew because the scoreboard said so. We win when the numbers win.

07 · Next steps

Three steps to momentum.

1

Sit with it

Share this with the team. Poke holes. Write down every hard question; we'd rather earn the yes than charm it.

2

Thursday, Sept 3

We meet, walk the plan end to end, and adjust scope until it fits. Bring the testimonials you're gathering; they slot straight into Pillar 03.

3

Kickoff Sept 4

Papers signed, strategy sprint starts same week. v2 gets its public moment on September 30, loaded instead of rushed, and six months of compounding follow.

Momentum, not fireworks.

Ray, you've built a product that tells business owners the truth about their future. Let us build the machine that tells the market about Profitual, and be straight with you about what each month should produce.